This article analyzes the advantages and disadvantages of each 3D scanning solution, helping engineers and businesses choose the right technology for measurement and reverse engineering.
3D scanning is becoming a crucial platform in geometric measurement, reverse engineering, and product improvement. Instead of relying entirely on 2D drawings or manual measurement methods, 3D scanning allows for the direct collection of real-world geometric data of objects with high detail, thereby creating 3D models for analysis, modification, and production.
In practice, handheld 3D scanning and stationary 3D scanning are the two most common solutions today. Although both methods aim to digitize shapes, their operating principles, applications, and data quality differ significantly, directly impacting project accuracy and efficiency.
Handheld 3D scanning is a method that uses a mobile scanning device, directly manipulated by engineers around the object to collect surface data. Handheld 3D scanners typically utilize laser or structured light technology, allowing for flexible scanning in various environmental conditions.
The outstanding advantage of handheld 3D scanning lies in its mobility. The device can access large details, complex geometries, or immovable objects such as large molds, machine bodies, steel structures, or machinery installed on-site. With high-end handheld 3D scanning systems, the data obtained fully meets the requirements for reverse engineering and technical measurement.
Fixed 3D scanning is a scanning method where the device is placed in a fixed position, and the object to be scanned is placed within the measurement area. This solution is commonly used in measurement rooms, laboratories, or quality control lines.
The advantages of fixed 3D scanning include good control over the measurement environment, minimal impact from vibrations, external light, and user interaction. For small details, high repeatability requirements, and standardized measurement processes, fixed 3D scanning offers good stability and automation.
However, fixed 3D scanning is limited by the size of the scanning area and geometric accessibility. For large objects or those with many hidden areas, this method is often not the optimal choice.
The core difference between handheld and fixed 3D scanners doesn't lie in which solution is "better," but rather in the intended use and practical deployment conditions.
Handheld 3D scanners are suitable for tasks requiring high flexibility, on-site work, and scanning large objects or complex geometries. Conversely, fixed 3D scanners are effective in controlled measurement environments, with small details, repetitive measurement processes, and automation requirements.
In terms of accuracy, both methods can achieve very high levels if the right equipment and procedures are used. However, in practical modification or reverse engineering projects, modern handheld 3D scanners often offer a distinct advantage due to their ability to maintain consistent accuracy across the entire model, even with large details.
In engineering projects, 3D scan data is only truly valuable when it can be converted into a usable CAD model. This is where the difference between 3D scanning solutions becomes clear.
Handheld 3D scanners, when combined with appropriate data processing and reverse engineering, allow for accurate reconstruction of the geometry of parts that no longer have drawings or have been deformed over time. Fixed 3D scanners can also serve reverse engineering purposes, but are often limited in size and overall geometric coverage.
In reality, the quality of a 3D scan depends not only on whether a handheld or fixed device is used, but also largely on the engineer's experience, the accuracy of the equipment, the measurement process, and how the data is processed after scanning.
If 3D scanning is implemented without clearly defining the output objective, such as measurement, reverse engineering, or modification, the resulting data may look good visually but lack the accuracy necessary for engineering use. This is a common reason why many businesses have scan files but cannot apply them in practice.
Instead of approaching 3D scanning as a single data collection step, 3D Master implements the entire scanning process based on the project's ultimate purpose. From the outset, the engineering team clearly defines whether the 3D scan data will be used for measurement, reverse engineering, modification, or manufacturing, thereby selecting the most suitable handheld or stationary 3D scanner for each specific engineering problem.
3D Master's technological platform is based on genuine Creaform 3D scanning systems, achieving micrometer-level accuracy and designed to work reliably with large details, complex geometries, or challenging measurement conditions. Combining specialized equipment and practical experience in various fields such as mechanical engineering, industry, heritage, and education, the 3D scan data obtained is not only geometrically accurate but also ready to be converted into engineering models for design, analysis, and manufacturing immediately.
3D Master scans a car in 3D using a Handyscan Creaform handheld 3D scanner.
In practical project implementation, handheld and stationary 3D scanners serve different engineering tasks. Stationary 3D scanning is suitable for small details, simple geometries, and repetitive measurement processes in a tightly controlled measurement room environment. However, this method is limited by the size of the scan area and the ability to access the overall geometry of the object.
Conversely, handheld 3D scanners show clear advantages in most current practical problems. With the ability to work directly on-site, flexibly access complex surfaces, and accurately scan large, immovable details, handheld 3D scanners become a suitable solution for most measurement, reverse engineering, and modification needs in industry.
In particular, modern generations of handheld 3D scanners have achieved high accuracy, stable data, and fully meet stringent technical requirements, not inferior to traditional fixed 3D scanning systems in measurement labs.
Both handheld and fixed 3D scanners play a certain role in the field of measurement and reverse engineering. However, considering flexibility, application scope, and deployment efficiency in real-world production conditions, handheld 3D scanners are the trend chosen by many businesses and engineers.
At 3D Master, the entire solution focuses on genuine handheld 3D scanner systems, allowing for efficient handling of measurement, reverse engineering, and geometric digitization problems in various fields. Choosing the right handheld 3D scanning technology from the outset not only helps control errors better but also optimizes time, cost, and the value of the scanned data.
If you need advice on the right handheld 3D scanning solution for your specific product or project, the 3D Master engineering team is ready to assist based on your actual technical requirements.
-->> See more: Genuine, high-quality, and affordable handheld 3D scanners at 3D Master
Hotline - Zalo - LINE - Telegram - WhatsApp - Viber - Kakaotalk: +84 982 089 198 | 0986333960
Email: cuong3dmaster@gmail.com | hung3dmaster@gmail.com | tech3dmaster@gmail.com
Website: https://3dmaster.com.vn
